Since peaking a little over a year ago, Tesla stock has fallen by more than 70%. It is understandable to wonder what has changed given the severity of this decline. However, there isn't much to explain. Tesla's valuation was wildly inflated, and it is now returning to a more reasonable level.
In November 2021, Tesla had an enterprise value of $1.2 trillion (market capitalization plus net debt). That was greater than the combined value of the next four most valuable automakers (Toyota, Volkswagen, Mercedes, and Ford). That is insane. Only 3.2% of light vehicle sales in the US in 2021 were electric vehicles. Tesla's peak valuation suggested that it would eventually rule a still-emerging industry. That is not a risky wager at all. Competition-wise, a lot can happen before the day when electric vehicles make up the majority of new car sales.
Is Tesla's price today reasonable? With about a third of Toyota's revenue, the company's enterprise value is currently comparable to that of Toyota. Compared to Toyota, its forward price/earnings ratio is 26. (all these figures come from Capital IQ).
26 times earnings is a high but not completely insane multiple. Tesla may also be worthwhile. It is growing revenue much more quickly than the major automakers — by 55% in the third quarter. Even more impressive are its 16% operating margin and 18% return on capital, both significantly higher than its major competitors. Tesla seems to have cost and capital efficiency advantages that will allow it to reinvest and grow in the future more than its large, sluggish rivals.
In conclusion, even though Tesla's valuation prices in a lot of positive news, it has moved beyond the point of outright madness. There is still a query. Has Tesla's CEO Elon Musk gone a little bit bonkers, and should that result in a discount on the company's stock? His management of that business, including the acquisition of Twitter, appears careless. Nobody knows what the future will bring. The entire development of Tesla's actions, as well as Elon Musk's activities, are out of sight.